The Bookshop

I’m SO glad that Enid Blyton provoked such a joyous reaction in you all; not even one derogatory comment. She obviously helped us all become obsessive readers. Though I’m on a St. Clare’s binge at the moment, my favourites are either Famous Five or The Naughtiest Girl in the School or the Six Cousins… tricky. Our Vicar’s Wife, and probably Our Vicar too, organised a Famous Five party for us once. Brilliant.

Now (and watch closely here, to see if you can spot the seams) Enid Blyton books could be bought in a bookshop, which brings me to The Bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald. Lynne Hatwell, aka dovegreyreader, very kindly gave this to me when we met earlier in the year, and it was just the right size to slip into my bag on the train today.

I tried a Penelope Fitzgerald novel last year, Human Voices, but not sure I got round to writing about it on here. It was one of those books which I finished before I quite felt that I’d got into it – the style was a little jabby and awkward, and somehow it didn’t click. And The Bookshop felt the same for the first thirty pages… but then, thank goodness, how wonderful, it all fell into place and hallelujah, I raced right to the end. From being a book I couldn’t get on with, it became one of my favourite reads this year.

Slim and simple, The Bookshop is about Florence Green setting up a bookshop in a small town called Hardborough, in 1959. The business meets genteel opposition from several quarters of the town, but also support from others. Christine, a stubborn and resilient young girl, comes to work as an assistant – and between Christine and Florence a rather touching, but unsentimental, friendship develops. If that sounds remotely mawkish, trust me, it isn’t. Penelope Fitzgerald doesn’t do mawkish. Her writing is spare, very spare, and there isn’t room for emotions – we simply see the people interact, and can quite easily understand the emotions they must be experiencing. How Florence faces opposition, how she accepts Christine’s characteristics and how she changes as a result of the bookshop.

The denouement is subtle and devastating – it involves neighbours acting as they would in a Mapp & Lucia book, where it would be a gentle comedy. Here it is understated tragedy. The Bookshop is a triumph of a novel, and I’m so glad Lynne gave it to me, and that *something* clicked whilst I was reading it.

Jolly Hockeysticks

Oh dear, did everyone go when I was in Northern Ireland? Hope someone is still reading! Perhaps this will get you to say something… I’m afraid I’m going to take a literary nosedive, and return to that which I mentioned a few days’ ago – Enid Blyton and the St. Clare’s stories!


I’ve probably mentioned here before that I grew up on Enid Blyton, reading little else for quite a few years – it does mean I missed out on some gems of children’s literature, but can always catch up now (I don’t believe you can ever be too old for a good book). Those doom-mongerers who wanted Blyton banned and thought she would provide nothing but illiteracy to generations of youngters would find it hard to say I don’t like books now… Blyton provides addictive, but harmless, stories which feed young imaginations and are almost limitless in their quantity.

I loved the St. Clare’s series, largely because the central characters are twins. Pat and Isabel actually shun the book stereotype of being either absolutely identical or wholly opposite – though perhaps they are a little too like each other. Neither want to go to St. Clare’s; within minutes of arriving they learn to be good eggs and to be true to their school and honest with their friends ya-dah-ya-dah. All enjoyable tripe. Blyton appears to have had a pathological hatred of ‘tell-tales’ (which always seems to me to be invented as an excuse for teachers to ignore the majority of children’s squabbles) and a fervour for sport, and Janet (in the ‘good egg’ category) is so bluntly rude that I wanted to push her down a well – despite all these things, I’ve been joyously reliving my youth through these books. Any Blyton fanatics out there? Any children’s books which can take you right back to your infancy – or do you avoid them on principle, in case your memories would be tarnished? I, for one, had no notion that Blyton used such a flood of exclamation marks…

Off to Somerset tomorrow, will be there for three weeks. On Friday I will hear whether or not Magdalen have granted me any funding… wish me luck!

Short Stories

As I mentioned earlier, Vulpes Libris are having a week about the short story, and for the first entry they asked a selection of bloggers to choose their favourite short story writers, collectioins or individual stories – and I contributed my views. Didn’t really have to think twice, go over here to see whom I choosed. Go forward to the next post over there to see Elaine’s (aka Random Jottings’) selection of short stories, and realising that she does like quite of them despite thinking she didn’t!

Year Two: Book Reviews

My second year isn’t finished yet, but I thought I’d make this an ongoing list – it seems silly to wait til the end of the year to make reviews accessible, so this will go over on the left hand side at the top, one of the quick links, and will be added to as and when!

3191 Blog – A Year of Mornings
Anand, Mulk Raj – Untouchable
Anderson, Sarah – Halfway to Venus
Arlen, Michael – The Green Hat
Austen, Jane – Northanger Abbey
Banks, Lynne Reid – The L-Shaped Room
Bennett, Alan – The History Boys
Benson, E.F. – The Mapp & Lucia series
Blyton, Enid – The St. Clare’s series
Brandenburg, Molly – Everyday Cat Excuses
Brinton, Sybil G. – Old Friends and New Fancies
Buzbee, Lewis – The Yellow-Lighted Bookshop
Carey, Edward – Alva & Irva
Carroll, Lewis – Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland
Cartwright, Justin – This Secret Garden: Oxford Revisited
Coetzee, J. M. – Foe
Coles, William – The Well-Tempered Clavier
Compton-Burnett, Ivy – A House and Its Head
Conrad, Joseph – Heart of Darkness
Crompton, Richmal – Frost at Morning
Delafield, E.M. – Straw Without Bricks: I Visit The Soviets
Devonshire, Deborah (Deborah Mitford) – Counting My Chickens
Dockrill, Laura – Mistakes in the Background
du Maurier, Daphne – The Flight of the Falcon
du Maurier, Daphne – My Cousin Rachel
du Maurier, Daphne – Letters from Menabilly
Eliot, T.S. – The Family Reunion
Ferguson, Rachel – The Brontes Went To Woolworths
Fitzgerald, Penelope – The Bookshop
Fraser-Sampson, Guy – Major Benjy
Freese, Matthias B. – Down To A Sunless Sea
Garnett, Angelica – Deceived With Kindness
Garnett, David – Aspects of Love
Gillard, Linda – Star Gazing
Grace, N.B. – High School Musical: The Book of the Film (!)
Hansford Johnson, Pamela – An Error of Judgement
Hill, Susan – The Battle for Gullywith
Humble, Nicola – The Feminine Middlebrow Novel
Jackson, Shirley – The Haunting of Hill House
Kendal, Felicity – White Cargo
Kennedy, Richard – A Boy at the Hogarth Press
Koppel, Lily – The Red Leather Diary
Leacock, Stephen – Literary Lapses
Lee, Harper – To Kill A Mockingbird
Light, Alison – Forever England
McEwan, Ian – Black Dog
Melbye, Eric – Tru
Milne, A.A. – Two People
Milne, Christopher – The Enchanted Places
The Mitfords – Letters Between Six Sisters
Morley, Christopher – Parnassus on Wheels
Nemirovsky, Irene – Suite Francaise
Niffenegger, Audrey – The Time Traveler’s Wife
Norton, Mary – The Bread and Butter Stories
Oliphant, Laurence – Piccadilly
Orwell, George – Homage to Catalonia
Oyeyemi, Helen – The Icarus Girl
Rice, Eva – The Lost Art of Keeping Secrets
Rosenthal, Amy – On The Rocks
Sacks, Oliver – The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat
Sackville-West, Vita – The Heir
Saki – The Penguin Complete Saki
Schein, Elyse & Paula Bernstein – Identical Strangers
Schreiner, Olive – The Story of an African Farm
Sellers, Susan – Vanessa and Virginia
Shaffer, Mary Ann – The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Smith, Emma – The Great Western Beach
Solomon, Laura – Alternative Medicine
Stacey, Tom – The Man Who Knew Everything
Stevenson, D.E. – Miss Buncle’s Book
Taylor, Elizabeth – Angel
Visman, Janni – Yellow
Warner, Sylvia Townsend – Lolly Willowes
Waterfield, Giles – The Long Afternoon
Waugh, Evelyn – Put Out More Flags
Whipple, Dorothy – Someone at a Distance
Wiseman, Robert – Quirkology
Woolf, Leonard & Trekkie Ritchie Parsons – Love Letters
Woolf, Virginia – Orlando
Yates, Richard – Revolutionary Road
Zusak, Markus – The Book Thief
Various – The Sixpenny Debt and other Oxford stories

Reviews by Our Vicar and Our Vicar’s Wife

Return! A plethora of books

I am back from a week in Northern Ireland and a weekend in Warwickshire, and hope some of you are still around – will try and pop into most of the blogs tomorrow to say hello and catch up, but too late to do that tonight. Instead, will give a round-up of three books I’ve read recently… that’s right, leave me alone for a week and I have to burst with bookish things. None of these three books would make my top ten of the year, but each was worth writing about – and that might be where the connections end. We’ll see if any more come up as I write…

Capuchin Classics kindly sent me another of their reprinted novels – Tom Stacey’s The Man Who Knew Everything, which was published as Deadline in 1988. If you’re thinking ‘Oh, wasn’t that a film with John Hurt and Imogen Stubbs?’ then I’ll stop you there – Stacey’s foreword to this slim novel makes it clear that he has no wish to be associated with that film. Despite talented actors, ‘the director and editor went to ground for three months to emerge inexplicably with an edited version, not readily intelligible, which re-shaped the story as a tragedy of love’. So, if it is not a tragedy of love, what is it? Granville Jones is an aging newspaper correspondent in the 1950s Gulf, writing occasional dispatches and mostly idling towards the end of his life, reflecting on the two women who have played significant roles therein. He is there when a coup threatens the island’s leader, also a personal friend, and must report on it – and must meet the journalistic deadline before anyone else gets there.

In some ways it’s a pity Stacey had to lose the title, as it lends the narrative an urgency which can’t always be felt by those who, like me, haven’t lived the journalist’s life. It doesn’t help that Granville isn’t a particularly likeable character (I felt more than a little sympathy for his abandoned family) but he does come into his own when in conversation with the island’s leader, the Emir. ‘We have grown old together, Jonas. You and I are too old to fear to die.’ All in all, an interesting novel with some touching moments, but requires a mind with a greater political bent than mine possesses.

Piccadilly by Laurence Oliphant was also a reprint, but my copy is a 1928 reprint of the 1870 original. Victorian literature forms too large a gap in my reading, which I decided to rectify with the shortest Victorian novel I owned. Piccadilly is described as a satire on London politics of the 1870s – well, I’m not particularly clued up on the political scene of that era, or indeed any era. No matter, I continued regardless. The hero, Frank Vanecourt, decides to launch himself on a life of selfless charity, and to write a book:

‘I shall tell of my aspirations and my failures – of my hopes and fears, of my friends and my enemies. I shall not shrink from alluding to the state of my affections; and if the still unfulfilled story of my life becomes involved with the destiny of others, and entangles itself in an inextricable manner, that is no concern of mine’.

It might not astonish you to learn that the story of his life does become involved with the destiny of others – specifically his noble (and quite lovable) friend Grandon; the woman Grandon loves, Lady Ursula; and Ursula’s mercenary mother Lady Broadhem. What unravels is a complex and often amusing plot of secrecy and blackmail and love and much introspection and expostulation from Vanecourt – presumably mocking a vogue for novels of this ilk. Some rather unsavoury, but perhaps inevitable, racism occasionally spoils what is quite a witty work, but I can’t help feel I’d appreciate Piccadilly more if I’d read any of the sort of novels which it mimicks.

Finally, a collection of short stories by Mathias B. Freese, Down to a Sunless Sea, which I was sent to review. Full marks on the title – I do like quotations in titles, as I might have mentioned before. Vulpes Libris are kicking off a week on short stories over on their blog, and very interesting I’m sure it will prove to be – whilst they’re at it, perhaps someone could answer a query. Why does the short story so often attract the macabre? I thought (and wrote!) quite a lot about the Victorian short story for a dissertation at university, but the macabre didn’t pop up nearly so often… Freese’s collection has large doses of it, and wasn’t always my cup of tea, shall we say. I did want to mention one story, though, which seemed head and shoulders above the rest – ‘Young Man’. It’s a little like Virginia Woolf’s The Waves in style, but communicates some sort of mental illness, in an atemporal confusion. If I could remember Genette’s Narrative Discourse, then all sorts of terms would be appropriate. This is part of it:

One day his daughter asked him, “What’s on TV for children tonight, Daddy?”
One day his wife said, “Someday it will be all right.”
One day he asked himself, “Is this it?”
Again his daughter asked him, “What’s on TV for children tonight, Daddy?”
“Watch me, instead,” he replied

Painting

Trying a little experiment just before I head off to Northern Ireland. When I posted about painting a while ago, someone said I should try selling things on Etsy – a place to sell amateur art. Well, thought I, perhaps I will – but I thought I’d test the water here. This might not be for the most regular visitors to Stuck-in-a-Book, who are literary-minded folk first and foremost, but perhaps I’ll be able to point people in this direction.

Anyway, I’m going to try and sell this painting Woman with Orange Background (acrylic, 40×30 cm.):


It’s going to be something of a silent auction, mostly because I haven’t the smallest idea how much one should charge for these things – so, if you’re interested, don’t write in the comments, but email me at simondavidthomas@yahoo.co.uk with an offer and your location, and I’ll get back to people when I’m back on English shores! I’ll find some college funding somehow…

Goodbyes

And I am now unemployed!

Thanks for your kind messages about funding – I’m not thinking about it for the next week, and will instead enjoy a week in Northern Ireland… might be a little damp, I hear. Still, I get to spend Saturday at the wedding of two friends, so that will be wonderful.

This evening I had a meal out with my two closest friends at work, Clare and Lucy, as it was my last day in the Bodleian. We don’t work in the same departments at the same time as each other, but always spend breaks and lunch together, and they are very, very dear to me. We’ve laughed our way through the year, and have dozens of in-jokes which would irritate everyone after moments. We all got each other parting gifts, and mine included two books: Mrs Woolf & the Servants by Alison Light, which I’ve had my eye on for ages, and The Autobiography of Sir Thomas Bodley. He of the Bodleian, you understand. One of our most repeated private jokes – basically, if you say ‘Sir Thomas… Bodley?’ eight hundred times, you’ll be a step closer to understanding why we laugh at the sound of his name.

So, off I go to Northern Ireland… with seven books. I probably will only finish one or two, but the idea of being stranded without books… doesn’t bear thinking about.


I’ve packed them now, so have to try and remember them from the photo…
-They Came Like Swallows by William Maxwell – a gift from Karen aka Cornflower
-A Passage to India by EM Forster – on my reading list for next term (have I updated you on reading lists yet? I fear not! More on’t soon)
-Piccadilly Jim by PG Wodehouse – been meaning to read more Wodehouse for ages, and borrowed this from my aunt Jacq years ago
-The Bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald – a gift from Lynne aka dovegreyreader
-The Man Who Knew Everything by Tom Stacey – review copy
-(not in picture) The Man Who Was Thursday by GK Chesterton – borrowed from Mel, my housemate

Flying Too Close To The Sun

The Icarus Girl by Helen Oyeyemi has been on the peripherals of my mind since someone mentioned it here – in fact, taking a quick trip down blogmory lane, I find it was Nichola aka Lost In Translation, back when I was talking about The Love Child by Edith Olivier, in my 50 Books… but that was only January, and I’m sure I’d heard of it before that. No matter. When Stephanie at Bloomsbury asked what sort of books I’d like her to send me, The Icarus Girl instantly came to mind.

Jessamy Harrison is an introverted, thoughtful and fanciful child, eight years old, with a fiery Nigerian mother and a softly spoken, slightly anxious, white English father. When she visits her mother’s family in Nigeria (Jessamy et al live in England) she also meets Titiola, or TillyTilly, a ragged girl of her own age who seems to be living secretly in the compound. TillyTilly’s friendship means a lot to Jessamy – but then TillyTilly also appears back in England, and grows more and more possessive in their friendship. What seemed to be an exciting but innocent friendship soon becomes a dangerous and terrifying one – both for Jessamy and for the reader.

I don’t think any review of this book has been written without expressing astonishment that Oyeyemi wrote The Icarus Girl whilst she was studying for her A Levels. It is pretty darn amazing, but this book would be extremely impressive whoever had written it. I love narratives which introduce an element of fantasy into an otherwise domestic setting – it’s what I hope to write a dissertation and possibly doctorate on – but Oyeyemi goes a step further than that, because the reader is constantly left uncertain. How much is real, how much is illness, how much is delusion? Jessamy is seeing a psychiatrist, but her sessions deliberately do not reveal much to the reader.

What starts as a novel about loneliness and isolation becomes infused with issues of obsession, possession, power and, most sophisticatedly, doubleness. I know ‘duplicity’ is probably the correct term, but doubleness is more to the point – even from TillyTilly’s first appearance (and her name!) when she simply repeats everything Jessamy says. It seems a little like those pieces of voice-activated-typing software, where they have to listen to your voice for a while, to register and recognise it, before the programme will work. Doubleness and identity become increasingly important through the novel, very cleverly.

Now, I like novels which don’t tell you everything – ambiguity is fine. My Cousin Rachel is an example from my recent reading. But I finished The Icarus Girl without a clue as to what was real, what the almost hallucinatory final chapter signified – but I also felt that the fault was mine. Someone who’s read it – is it clear? Should I have been able to work things out? It doesn’t alter my opinion of the novel, though – it is exceptional, and I look forward to reading more of Oyeyemi’s work.

In less happy news, for those of you who’ve read this far, the Arts & Humanities Research Council decided not to give me any money for my Masters next year… the next step is college funding, and the step after that is bankruptcy! But I’m determined to do the course, and will keep praying.

Oxford Stories

I’ve been attending my very first book launch! Not for my book, you understand, but for The Lost College & other Oxford stories, a collection by OxPens, a group of writers in Oxford. Last year they very successfully published The Sixpenny Debt & other Oxford stories, which I’ve read *almost* all of, and most of the authors make a repeat performance the second time around – and, what’s more, have secured the approval of Colin Dexter. He, who indirectly provides most of the University’s funding through Morse filming, was at the launch, and gave a kind, unassuming and funny talk. Also suggested that a potential future short story title could be ‘The Identity of the Second Dog Handler’…


Keen followers of Stuck-in-a-Book will recognise a few names from OxPens – Mary Cavanagh (The Crowded Bed), Margaret Pelling (Work For Four Hands… still haven’t reviewed this, but it’s very readable!) and Jane Gordon-Cumming (A Proper Family Christmas – now back in print! ) It was very nice to meet Jane and Margaret, and to see Mary again – this blog really has given me all sorts of lovely opportunities.

I can’t review The Lost College etc. because I only bought it a few hours ago, but there were some very promising readings from the authors included. I especially like the sound of Sheila Costello’s ‘Rabbit Fenley and The Body in the Garden’. Having read The Sixpenny Debt etc., though, I’ll chat about that, in the hope that I’ll have read The Lost College etc. by the time the next anthology comes out… I always find it so difficult to find anything unifying to say about short story collections, so it is a blessing that OxPens have done this for me – all the stories in both collections are connected with Oxford. That can be quite far-ranging, I’ll admit – from Tchiakovsky’s posthumous visit to the Sheldonian through to the accidental stealing of a library book in the distant past, from the confusion arising when a child understands everything adults say entirely literally, to the dangers of cycling in Port Meadow. My two favourite stories, though, are both connected with the middle classes committing murder… what does that say about me? Jane Gordon-Cumming’s Education in Action opens: ‘Dulcie was the scourge of the evening class. Which one? No, I don’t mean any class in particular. Dulcie was the Scourge of the Evening Class, generic. And I use the term loosely, to include day-time classes, weekend courses, summer schools – Dulcie was the scourge of the lot.’ You know the sort… The Rising Price of Property by Laura King contains an ingenious motive for murder, and is wonderfully cynical.

For a taste of Oxford from its real residents, though with real life being something usually foreign to these collections, do seek out The Sixpenny Debt & other Oxford stories or, I’m sure, The Lost College & other Oxford stories. Me, I’m just excited about having been to a book launch.

I’m back! / Mockingbirds and Cousins

Hurray! The internet has arrived at Marlborough Road!

For those of you thinking “That’s not news, you blogged on Saturday”, I have to say – that wasn’t me. Well, in a way it was, but it was a phantom post – I tried to link to the video on Youtube a couple of weeks ago, and failed. Obviously it was hanging around in the ether, waiting for someone to authorise it or something, and suddenly it appeared at the weekend. Strange.

I’m afraid my return to the blogosphere will be short-lived, since I’m away on holiday on Friday, and back on 29th August – so more then. I do hope some people are still here, even with all the disruptions of late… blame the world of technology which eludes me. Thankfully one of my housemates has a very savvy boyfriend, who kindly tip-tip-tapped away at the keyboard and got everything sorted out. I am living proof that young + male doesn’t necessarily = good at internetty things. In fact, if you use the word ‘internetty’, then you probably don’t qualify. Though I once plugged an ethernet cable in upside down (no easy task), so I’m in a league of my own.

In the time I’ve been away from blogging, I’ve had quite a build-up of books to talk about, so that will probably take us up til I head off to Northern Ireland. Today I’m going to write about the last two book group books I’ve read in recent weeks, both classics of the twentieth century.

My Cousin Rachel is the third novel I’ve read by Daphne du Maurier – I wrote about The Flight of the Falcon here, having not been overwhelmed, but Rebecca is one of my favourite novels. My Cousin Rachel probably fell between the two. (There are some spoilers here, but not too many…) It tells the story of Ambrose and Philip Ashley, cousins who are more or less father and son, living in Cornish rural simplicity, away from women and contentedly reliant upon one another. Ambrose is taken off to Italy, and it is here that he meets and marries Rachel – and dies. Rachel comes to see Philip in England, and he is prepared to hate her – but their relationship becomes increasingly complicated, as does the readers’ thoughts about Rachel’s potential culpability.

The novel has a lot in common with Rebecca – and not just the setting. The same intrigue, power, and issues about what is left unspoken in relationships. Though not as successful as Rebecca – I found the first 80 pages dragged a little, in fact until Rachel arrived – My Cousin Rachel is brilliantly successful in the sense that I have never left a novel so uncertain as to a character’s guilt or lack of it – and either interpretation seems quite valid. Brilliantly done. There are such sophisticated themes of obsession and attracting obsession without being aware of it, the cyclical nature of the men’s experiences… The group discussing the novel were divided from absolute loathing to absolute loving, and thus an ‘interesting’ meeting was held!

My other book group were rather more agreed on To Kill A Mockingbird. This is one The Carbon Copy has been telling me to read for years, and I’ve continually meant to, so was glad when someone recommended it for book group and spurred me on. What a great book. I don’t think there’s any point in me giving a synopsis, since almost everyone has read this novel before me, but having seen the film I was surprised that so little of the book was concerned with the trial of Tom Robinson. To Kill A Mockingbird is much more a depiction of Southern life for the Finch family, and a portrait of a daughter’s relationship with her father – and a beautiful portrait at that. When I did the Booking Through Thursday about heroes, Colin put forward Atticus Finch, and I have to agree. The man is incredible – a very worthy father, a moralistic lawyer and a humble citizen, a combination which is tricky to write without seeming unrealistic or irritating. Atticus, though, remains wholly admirable and likeable throughout, and is one of the great male characters in literature, I’d say. I could eulogise about him, and this novel, for ages – but I won’t. I want to hear what you think.

There, written about two books without quoting from either of them. Tsk. Here’s one I like: “If I didn’t take this case (Scout) then I wouldn’t be able to hold my head up, I wouldn’t be about to tell anyone what to do, not even you and Jem.” Or this:

“I’m no idealist to believe firmly in the integrity of our courts and in the jury system – that is no ideal to me, it is a living, working reality. Gentlemen, a court is no better than each man of you sitting before me on this jury. A court is only as sound as its jury, and a jury is only as sound as the men who make it up. I am confident that you gentlemen will review without passion the evidence you have heard, come to a decision, and restore this defendant to his family. In the name of God, do your duty.”