Two final #1936Club titles

I’ve never read more books for a club year – for the first time, I’ve read more than there are days in the club week. (Or, indeed, in any week.) So I’m going to double up with a couple of reads that I don’t really have that much to say about… sorry to end on an anti-climax, but do check out the links round up for lots more suggestions. My favourites from my reading week were Miss Linsey and Pa by Stella Gibbons and Laughing Gas by P.G. Wodehouse. I won’t be blogging for a week, but will update with any links I missed when I’m back – and have scheduled a post for tomorrow saying what the next club year will be!

Anyway, onto my final two reads…

Houses as Friends by Dorothy Pym

I didn’t know much about Dorothy Pym – no relation of Barbara – but I bought this in a little bookshop in Fowey because the title intrigued me. I thought it might be about houses in fiction, or houses in general, but it is basically Pym’s autobiography through the different houses she lived in. Edwin Lutyens even wrote the introduction.

The houses are all rather grand and wonderful, and she was certainly brought up in privilege, married someone equally rich, and lived bountifully. I ended up knowing quite a lot of anecdotes, but still didn’t know a lot about who she was in essentials. And all the anecdotes were told rather plainly, without the sprinkle of magic that brings them alive, or makes them sound more exciting than they truly are. All in all, I enjoyed it as a period piece, but I found it lent a little too close to dullness. And I don’t really remember anything in it, already. Not one to rush to.

No Place Like Home by Beverley Nichols

I adore Bev, though have been a bit up and down with his non-fiction. The ups are VERY up, and I love the Merry Hall series to distraction, but others – like his investigation into spiritualism – didn’t really work for me. I’d assumed No Place Like Home would be one of his books about his house, but it turned out to be the opposite: it’s travel literature. Specifically of one long trip through Eastern Europe, to Egypt, to Israel, to Turkey and Greece. Not in that order. Rather than write a full review, I’ve come up with some pros and cons. And please head to Karen’s 1936 Club review of it for more detail – and also less uncertain enthusiasm for it!

Pros

  • Beverley is always pretty funny – depending, of course, on what you find funny. I really enjoyed his grumpy take on the Pyramids and the Sphinx.
  • It’s a great snapshot of 1936 across Europe, at least from one man’s perspective – he makes reference to Hitler that show his views were no secret at the time, though Nichols doesn’t seem to realise it’s the last time for a while that this sort of trip would be possible
  • His perspective on being in the Holy Land is very moving, and he does experience genuine connection with Jesus by seeing the places that He went (and railing against those areas that haven’t been upheld)
  • His vehemence against animal cruelty is welcome to me, and some of his views were probably very ahead of their time

Cons

  • …and some of his views weren’t. He is rather xenophobic at times. He is very against antisemitism, and then is antisemitic himself a few pages later… in general, the people of other countries are not as good as the Brits, in his eyes, and it made for some uneasy reading
  • The ‘Irate Reader’ he introduces to have a duologue with every now and then didn’t really work for me. In another mood it might have done, but I found it a little irritating
  • I just don’t love travel writing that much! I find it often leans towards the visual, which I find hard to translate in my head, and I also prefer people writing about their own countries and times – to give a deeper authenticity and grounding to their writing.

SO there you go. Neither of these are my favourite reads for the 1936 Club, but this club has been my favourite one, I think. So many interesting titles, so much going on in the world, and a brilliant cross-section shared from across the blogging community. Thanks, as ever, for reading, reviewing, commenting and sharing in the fun!

8 thoughts on “Two final #1936Club titles

  • April 18, 2021 at 11:02 am
    Permalink

    Enjoyed the reviews, although neither book is really something I’d check out. I’m sorry I missed this club year, which was really exciting (I’m catching up on the posts) and I’m now aiming to participate in the next one!

    Reply
  • April 18, 2021 at 1:01 pm
    Permalink

    An interesting final pairing of book, Simon. This is probably the Beverley I’ve felt most ambivalent about, although there was enough of his prose for me to enjoy (and the Irate Reader didn’t annoy me as it did you!) I think I’ll definitely try one of his garden ones next, though…

    Reply
  • April 18, 2021 at 1:59 pm
    Permalink

    You are such a nice man, Simon! I love the sentence, “It lent a little too close to dullness.”
    And yet your reviews never leave me in doubt of whether I want to read the books. Thank you.

    Reply
  • April 18, 2021 at 3:21 pm
    Permalink

    It’s been a great week Simon – so many interesting reads! Thanks to you and Karen for organising it.

    Reply
  • April 18, 2021 at 5:38 pm
    Permalink

    This has been a super week, so many excellent books and I was really glad I could join in!

    Reply
  • April 18, 2021 at 5:47 pm
    Permalink

    Am I too late? Just finished Robert Graves’ “Antigua Penny, Puce” from 1936:

    Light hearted, far fetched but quite entertaining tale of rival siblings. Brother Oliver is a generally unsympathetic boy, with an interest in stamps. His much cleverer younger sister – someone who will not let a matter drop till she wins- is made co-owner of the collection.
    Years on, with Oliver an author, and sister Jane a highly successful theatre owner and business woman, she seeks to regain her half of the stamps. Including the eponymous rare one.
    The rights of ownership of that specimen, however, prove to be a legal minefield- it was purloined by Jane’s scientist chum, Edith- a lady secretly infatuated with Jane’s much derided brother…
    Quite an enjoyable light read.

    Reply
  • April 19, 2021 at 9:54 pm
    Permalink

    I seem to have enjoyed No Place Like Home more than you did, but had forgotten that I had read it, well it was back in 2013. You might enjoy his Uncle Samson more, about his travels in the US. I really enjoyed the 1936 Club.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: