I loved The Man Who Planted Trees by Jean Giono when I read it years ago – a beautifully simple story – and have been meaning to read more Giono ever since. I did start Hill once and didn’t get very far, but 25 Books in 25 Days seemed like a good opportunity to read Melville (1941 – translated from French by Paul Eprile).
It started life as the introduction to Giono’s translation of Moby Dick, and can very loosely be said to be about Herman Melville. But this Melville is very much of Giono’s own invention, as Edmund White explains in his helpful introduction to the NYRB Classics edition. Which is, incidentally, beautiful. Giono’s Melville is solidly masculine and determined, and his life is shaped partly by visions of an angel who encourages him to write the novel that is in his heart – and an Irish nationalist called Adelina, who apparently didn’t exist.
Did I enjoy the book? I don’t know, really. It is very overblown, stylistically, in a way that feels deliberate. It is impressionistic and philosophical, interlaced with conversations that are often very funny. It is more of a word picture than a narrative, and swirls around like the waves hiding Moby Dick. Yes, it was often beautiful. But it was more of an experience than a narrative, if that makes sense. I think I should re-read it one day.
He was seeing clearly. He could say it to himself, there, alone in his bed, while a broad smile moistened his whiskers: “I don’t live to keep an eye on my commercial interests. I live to keep an eye on the gods.” What’s more, he’d be ready to earn his keep, starting tomorrow if necessary, doing no matter what kind of work, even something other than writing. Not a “man of letters” in the least.
On this evening, he felt strangely free, strangely decided. He called out softly, “Are you there?” No, the fire was dying out. The embers were crackling, that was all. “That one,” he said, “as soon as he wins, he takes off. Well, as soon as he believes he’s won, because – hold on a minute there, boy! – it hasn’t been stated yet that I will write this book.”
Truly, he didn’t feel he was capable of it, unless he had a real change of heart. He looked at the sailor’s clothes he’d just bought, lying over there on the armchair. What’s he scheming? he thought. What does he have in store for me? What’s he going to turn me into?
Giano was a scam artist–the man who planted trees did not exist. Reader’s Digest
magazine asked him to write a piece for the column about an unforgettable character and that is what he came up with. Years later, a journalist visited the ‘tree planting’ area and found it was
an heavily industrialized area. No trees then or ever. Gaiano explained away the hoax by saying Reader’s Digest had not specified that the character be a real person.
I’ve also had a mixed experience with Giono. Like you, I really liked The Man Who Planted Trees, but I couldn’t get on so well with The Horseman on the Roof. I do think he’s a really interesting writer though, and I’ll look out for this, it sounds unusual and immersive.
Yes, I think he’s perhaps a more complex or difficult writer than I realised at the outset.
How are you even managing this challenge? I do salute you! Where are you finding the time?! I’ve not even managed to read all your reviews …
I’m going for short books, which helps!! And getting up a bit earlier. It makes me realise how much more I could be reading, if I chose to…
Sounds rather odd but I liked the quote, even though I don’t fully understand it, I think. I should imagine immersing yourself so deeply in Moby Dick as to be able to translate it might be quite likely to turn a person odd… ;)
Haha, a very good point! It definitely would. And, yes, I found I quite liked a lot of it without understanding it.
Doesn’t sound like I’d enjoy this one.
Perhaps not!
I like the idea of book-as-an-experience, because sometimes that’s all they are – but they’re not necessarily the worse for that. And seconded what Liz says – I’m mightily impressed at managing a book and a review a day for 25 days – whew!
Yes, it’s a certain sort of book, for sure! I guess you just have to be in the mood for that sort of thing.
Ooooh! I’d not heard about this one, thank you for drawing my attention to it. It sounds weird, and challenging, but both in the best ways. I’ve been wanting to learn a bit more about Melville, but couldn’t bring myself to pick up a dry straight-up-and-down biography, so this sounds like just the ticket!