I really should start making better note of where I get my book recommendations, because I do like to acknowledge them properly. All I know is that Mr Blandings Builds His Dream House by Eric Hodgins (1946) had been on my Amazon wishlist for quite a few years when I bought a copy in the US in 2015. And what a nice copy it is – or was; it rather fell apart as I read it, sadly. Though perhaps appropriately. Anyway, many thanks to whoever suggested it!
Project Names brought this one to the fore. Indeed, when I was thinking about reading books with names in the title, as a loose project, it was this novel that came to mind first. I didn’t know anything about it. I haven’t seen the 1948 Cary Grant film, though I’d be keen to, and I kept getting it mixed up with V.S. Naipaul’s A House for Mr Biswas (which I haven’t read, but I imagine is very different). I love books about houses, I love books from the ’40s, and I was excited to start it. And, you know what? It’s great fun.
The sweet old farmhouse burrowed into the upward slope of the land so deeply that you could enter either its bottom or middle floor at ground level. Its window trim was delicate and the lights in its sash were a bubbly amethyst. Its rooftree seemed to sway a little against the sky, and the massive chimney that rose out of it tilted a fraction to the south. Where the white paint was flecking off on the siding, there showed beneath it the faint blush of what must once have been a rich, dense red.
It’s not often that the title of a novel sums up the whole plot, but it pretty much does here. It’s unusual for a novel to have a single arc of action, uninterrupted by subplots or a broader scope, but Mr Blandings Builds His Dream House is that book. It’s very impressive. Whenever I’m trying to write, I find sustaining the interest – and sufficient words – for a full scene is often quite tricky. In this novel, Hodgins starts with Mr and Mrs Blandings house-hunting, and steadily takes us through every moment of the process of finding and buying the house, changing their mind about what to do next, hiring an architect, constructing a property, and getting the fittings in. More impressively, it is very funny and very engaging.
I particularly love reading about every step of house buying/building/decorating when I’m not having to do it myself. And thank goodness I didn’t read this while I was buying my own flat, because every stage of the process goes wrong. Not in a Laurel and Hardy broad comedy way, but through a very believable series of mishaps and poor decisions. Whether it is the estate agent’s bluster, or the architect’s lack of realism, or the difficulty of finding a water source, everything adds a complication. Mr and Mrs Blandings blunder on, squabbling and occasionally remorseful, but keeping their vision of a completed home in mind.
The most remarkable thing about Hogdins’ writing is its even pace, and the way that it is clearly unhurried while still keeping the reader hooked. Ultimately we know that nothing particularly momentous is likely to happen, and the humour is kept up so we never feel too much like we’re witnessing a tragedy. My only major quibble with this edition (and, I believe, most other editions) is the illustrator. William Steig is well regarded, but his cartoons lean heavily towards the broad and fantastical, and are (to my mind) completely out of keeping with the tone of the book. It’s a shame, because he would definitely enhance a different type of book, but I found myself rather dreading them appearing. It spoiled the effect of the restrained, human prose.
But yes, what a fun, clever, well written book. Nothing showy or over the top, and the perfect thing to read if you are well settled in a house you don’t want to sell, renovate, or decorate.
I rather like the sound of this one (I am a little bit obsessed about houses, although at the moment I don’t have the energy or the finances to move or build or renovate). But it’s getting quite rare to have a single-issue story and a clear chronological plot.
Yes, it’s quite special for that!
I’ve been wanting to read this for a while because I love the film starring Cary Grant.
It seems everyone has seen the film!
I read this when I was doing my Reading New England project (for Connecticut) and also enjoyed it. The film is worth seeing, and it’s interesting that a “Mr Blandings dream house” craze was set off with replicas of the built around the country for a promotional gimmick. Another real-life note – the author nearly went bankrupt building his own house and had to sell it at a loss only two years later. After selling the movie rights to his book, he tried to buy it back but was unsuccessful. Dreams are expensive…
Fun! And thanks for the info about the replica houses – how fascinating!
I’d not heard of this book or the author before, but this does sound good. I also like books about houses. So sorry your lovely edition has suffered, I had that happen when reading quite an old book.
I know, it was sad! I was deliberately not taking it to work, to try and preserve it longer, but it was too fragile.
I have seen the movie but didn’t know there was a book. It sounds like the book is better. I might look for it.
Good luck!
I too had heard of the film but not the book – I must say it sounds lovely, rather like a gentler version of “The Money Pit” (one of Mr. Kaggsy’s favourite films). I’d frankly be inclined to watch the Blandings film whatever it was like – anything with Cary Grant has to be good! ;D
It’s definitely somehow gentle, despite so many calamities. And yes, I loved Cary in The Bishop’s Wife recently.
Another push for the movie. I haven’t read the book, so I am not sure how closely the movie follows the story, but it is charming. Cary Grant and Myrna Loy are perfect as the Blandings. Her scene with the painters is one of my favorite movie moments.
Thanks! There is certainly a funny section with painters in the book, though I imagine they’ve embellished it well.
I can only echo Annie D’s comment above — Myrna Loy’s scene with the house painters is one of the funniest ever committed to film. Highly recommended.
I really will have to seek this out!
I’m fortunate to have a good 1st edition copy from Simon & Schuster, New York, published the year I was born. It’s great to see that others love the paint color selection scene from the film, which Myrna Loy played to perfection. My husband refers to it every time we purchase paint for household projects. Although it’s a Hollywood version of the book, do try to see the film, Simon. In addition to Cary Grant and Myrna Loy, the cast includes many outstanding character actors of that era.
Ha, lovely that it’s become part of the family vernacular! I will try to see it, but it doesn’t seem to be available on the usual networks.
Forgot to include my name!