In The Dark Room by Brian Dillon – #FitzcarraldoFortnight

When Karen and Lizzy announced that they’d be doing a Fitzcarraldo Fortnight, I thought it would be a great opportunity to read some of the Fitzcarraldo Editions I’ve been bulk buying since I read the brilliant The Little Art by Kate Briggs. And I decided to start with one that’s been on my shelf for a year or so – In the Dark Room by Brian Dillon, originally published in 2005 and published as a Fitzcarraldo Edition thirteen years later.

The book is about memory and about grief. Dillon is looking back on the death of his parents – his mother, from a long and horrible illness that affected every part of her body, slowly killing her; his father, from a sudden heart attack. And he starts in the house that he is packing up, a few years after his father has died and after disputes with his brothers. The starting point is the memory that is held in objects, in houses, in the things that surround us – and the mixed blessing this can be for a family that has always had an anxious undercurrent, with things unsaid and other things too hastily said.

The first section is on houses, and the book opens as though we were being directed to the house. It’s impossible to write about houses and memory without quoting Gaston Bachelard, and perhaps without feeling that Bachelard already did it all perfectly in The Poetics of Space – but Bachelard wasn’t anywhere near as personal as Dillon. His writing is raw and doesn’t shy away from difficult emotions. It is also filled with brilliant, pithy moments like this:

A house changes after somebody has died: there is suddenly too much space.

In the Dark Room is constantly on the fine line between beautiful, observational style and being overwritten. I’ll admit: every time I picked it up, the sentences seemed over-wrought, always using the longest words where shorter ones would have done the same…

I have gradually surrounded myself with objects which trace the most random pathways into the past I am now trying to map. I feel myself dispersed, fragmented among these relics, quite unable to fit them into a logical sequence. I can dimly imagine such a story; a whole narrative, properly autobiographical, a propulsion towards the sort of self-knowledge that can conceive of itself as some kind of culmination.

Here’s the thing, though. After a paragraph or two, I always found that I had adjusted my mind accordingly. I lifted it to his register. And, perhaps because it is so consistent, it very quickly didn’t jar at all. My colleague John came up with the perfect analogy – it’s like swimming in the sea, that the cold only hurts for the first few minutes.

The title of the book is, of course, a reference to the place where photographs are developed. And this isn’t just a metaphor for the way in which memories gradually gain or lose clarity – there is a lot in the book about the few photographs that Dillon has of his parents. He cannot relate to the families who have albums full of them – he has a mere handful from their lives, and uses these to describe their lives, their relationship, their milestones. He makes the best of his paltry research materials, using their very insufficiency as inspiration.

I say ‘he cannot relate’ to them – there are quite a few times Dillon seems almost cartoonishly unable to relate to other people’s experiences. One that stuck out bizarrely to me is his mother’s Bible – she has highlighted a passage from 2 Corinthians that is a beautiful, wonderful passage about God’s grace and His ability to work through imperfect humans, and Dillon can’t comprehend that it could bring her joy. He is unable to see past his own prejudices. Similarly, we know that he has a fraught relationship with his brothers – but we never really learn why, or what they might think, or what led to it. They are his parents’ children too.

On the other hand, he is mesmerically good at writing about illness. The slow revelation of the illness his mother had, and the way in which he enables the reader to understand the frustration, agony, hopelessness that she must have felt, is done brilliant,y – and illness is notoriously difficult to convey, let alone at one remove.

So, In the Dark Room is perhaps a book of paradoxes. A deeply personal book that retains unexpected hiding places; an insightful book that can be oddly closed-minded; a beautiful book that takes time to adjust to. Overall – yes – a triumph that is as flawed as any individual, and both as patchy and as affecting as memory.

5 thoughts on “In The Dark Room by Brian Dillon – #FitzcarraldoFortnight

  • February 25, 2020 at 1:24 am
    Permalink

    I’ve never read any Fitzcarraldo Editions but I know of them by reputation. I have always assumed they would be too erudite for me to enjoy. Well, I did try Pond by Claire-Louise Bennett, which was published in the U.S. by a different publisher I think. Not really my cup of tea though.

    Interestingly, this is the second review of this book! Reese over at Typings also read it for the FitzcarraldoFortnight.

    Reply
  • February 25, 2020 at 11:36 am
    Permalink

    This is going on my wishlist, it sounds rather beautiful. I like books that explore memory (that’s usually fiction for me, I admit). Having lost my dad in 2007 I know how greif and memory work together. Sometimes in a comforting way, sometimes it’s just tough. Small, valueless objects suddenly full of meaning.

    Reply
  • February 25, 2020 at 12:51 pm
    Permalink

    Lovely review Simon. I’ve read Dillon’s other book and enjoyed it immensely, but in some ways I wish I’d read this one first. I love what your friend says about the style – you really *do* have to adjust to some books, but once you’re in they’re brilliant. My dad passed away in 2015 and the raw wound took a long time to settle (if it really has). This is going straight onto the wishlist.

    Reply
  • February 25, 2020 at 4:11 pm
    Permalink

    Excellent review–“I lifted it to his register. ” Well said. Sadly, I think there are many today who just dismiss any Bible passage–not even seeing the beauty of the language, regardess of faith. Excellent work.

    Reply
  • February 26, 2020 at 9:00 am
    Permalink

    Hm… I’m thinking… maybe not for me. But a wonderfully insightful review.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: